What Size is a Standard Pie Dish?
/What size is a standard pie dish, anyway?
Generally speaking, a standard size pie dish is 9 inches (23 cm).
It gets tricky, though, because pie dishes are not standardized in measurements or how they’re measured. More on that later.
The Conundrum of Pie Dish Sizes
Have you ever made a pie recipe and been disappointed that the pie doesn’t adequately fill the pie dish? Or conversely, had way too much filling that you then didn’t know what to do with or maybe it came bubbling out while baking and made a mess of your oven?
Why do pies turn out looking different than the pictures in the recipe, even though you used the pie pan size called for?
While we’re at it, why are there so many different names for the round vessel in which we bake pies: pie dish, a pie pan, pie plate, and pie tin?? Which one do you say?
These are the deep questions that plague me throughout the day, bogging me down until they are satisfactorily answered. This is why I can’t simply “make a pie.” Making a pie inevitably turns into wondering which pie dish I should use, why we have at least 4 different sizes, and why there need to be so many.
Helpful recipes will specify which size pie dish is called for, but what if you don’t have that size? What if you use what you have anyway but the recipe doesn’t fill your pan or it’s too much? If you want to make that kind of pie again, do you find a new recipe, or buy a new pie dish? Or do you take the time to adjust all the measurements to better fit your pie tin?
WHY are there so many questions surrounding just one small aspect of making a pie? Let’s do our best to clear things up.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase using these links, Jennyblogs may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you. This helps to support Jennyblogs. Where possible, links are prioritized to small businesses and ethically and responsibly made items. For further information see the privacy policy. Grazie!
Lack of Standardization in Pie Dishes
There is no standardization in pie dish measurements which can make choosing one a bit difficult. While most would consider 9 inches (23 cm) as standard, there are several other factors that go into pie dishes that can make them differ dramatically.
You could order several different 9 inch (23 cm) pie dishes from various companies, bake the same pie recipe in each one, and the pies would probably all come out differently. Side height, the angle of the side slope, if there is and how big the lip might be, if the edge is fluted or fancy, all will affect how the final pie looks. One brand’s 9 inch (26 cm) pie pan measuring from outer edge to outer edge is quite different to another brand’s 9 inch (23 cm) pie pan measuring from inner edge to inner edge.
Since these aspects aren’t standardized, let’s dive into the various options.
Three Aspects to Consider When Choosing a Pie Dish
Pie Dish Diameter: The most important aspect to consider is the pie plate’s diameter. There is some discrepancy here as some are measured from outer edge to outer edge, some inner edge to inner edge, and others the diameter of the bottom of the plate. On top of that, many manufacturers don’t specify how their pie dishes are measured.
Pie Dish Depth: Pie dishes also vary in height - shallow, regular, and deep dish. This is also not standardized, but most standard dishes fall between 1.5 - 2 inches (4 - 5 cm). A shallow pie dish could be as low as 1 inch (2.5 cm), and a deep dish is often 2 inches (5 cm) or deeper.
Pie Dish Capacity: Another important indicator is the capacity of a pie dish. 4-6 cups or 1 - 1.5 Qts (.95 - 1.4 L) is common, with anything less being a smaller pie pan and anything more being a bigger pie pan.
If I want to have just 1 pie dish on hand, which size should I have?
9 inches (23 cm) will be your best bet all around, with a height of 1.5 - 2 inches (4 -5 cm). Things to consider:
If you’re buying just one pie pan to have on hand, it would be safer to have a slightly greater capacity, so go with deep dish 9 inch (23 cm) and look for one with sides are about 2 inches (5 cm) high.
If you most often make fruit pies, go with a 9 inch (23 cm) with higher sides. No one likes a fruit pie that bubbles over and leaves a mess or worse, ends up dry because so much of the filling bubbled over.
Cream pies, often those with graham cracker crusts (key lime pie, peanut butter pies, etc.) often do better in a 9 inch (23 cm) pie plate or one with shorter sides, closer to 1.5 inches (4 cm) or even less depending on the pie. I’ve made too many cream pies that looked dwarfed by the pie pan they were made in.
Ideally, if you make pies often, you’d have two or three different pie dish sizes on hand. A shorter 9 inch (23 cm) for cream pies, a deeper 9 (23) or even 10 inch (26 cm) for fruit pies, and a more standard size 9 inch (23 cm) for everything in between.
My favorite to work with is ceramic, with simple beauty added to each pie and even browning of crusts. They’re also a good choice for helping to keep crusts from slipping or shrinking down.
Favorite Brand of Pie Dishes
Even beyond pie dishes, Emile Henry is one of my absolute favorite bakeware companies. Emile Henry is a French brand, made in France and very high quality.
They’re elegant, a breeze to clean, and come in various sizes. Emile Henry bakeware can be quite pricy, but their pie dishes aren’t actually too much more than other pie dishes on Amazon. For the investment, it’s well worth it.
Between my mom and I, we have four different Emile Henry pie dishes, which means I can accurately measure four different styles and compare them to their online measurements to see how they add up.
Emile Henry Pie Dishes:
Shape Code: 61.31 - 10 inches (26 cm)
My actual pie plate has stamped on the bottom that it is “26 cm” and “9 in.” When I measured the pie plate, the 26 cm is correct, which is actually 10.25 inches. This means the stamped “9 in” is incorrect. Their website lists it as 10 inches. From this I gather that their dimensions are measured from outer edge to outer edge.
The inner edge to inner edge measurement is 9 inches (23 cm).
Capacity 1.5 Qt (1.4L).
The sides are 2 inches tall (5 cm).
Ceramic Shape Code 61.21 - 10.25 inches (26 cm)
10.25 inches (26 cm) measured from outer edge to outer edge.
The inner measurement 9.25 inches (23.5) cm.
Capacity 1.7 Qt.
Sides are 2.6 inches (6.5 cm) tall.
Shape Code 61.62 - 9 inches (23 cm)
This Emile Henry pie dish is no longer available on their site and I couldn’t find really any other source selling this particular shape code, so the only measurements I have to go on are my own.
9 inches (23 cm) measured from outer edge to outer edge.
The inner edge to inner edge measurement is 8 inches (20 cm).
Sides are 2 inches (5 cm) at the tallest part of the lightly ruffled edge.
Shape Code 61.81
This pie dish is no longer available on the Emile Henry website, but it looks fairly similar in size to the other 10 inch plates above.
10.5 inches (26.5 cm) measured outer edge to outer edge.
9.25 inches (23.5 cm) measured inner edge to inner edge.
Sides are just shy of 2.25 inches (6 cm) tall.